In recent years, two factories have risen to prominence in the field of high-end Rolex replicas: Clean Factory and VS Factory (also known as VSF). This article will comprehensively compare the two factories on key quality parameters to help enthusiasts make an informed purchasing decision.
1. Movement comparison
VS Factory
Uses self-developed VS3135 movement (for Submariner/Datejust) and VS3235 movement (for new watches)
VS3235 movement has 72 hours power reserve
Functions close to original, including smooth crown operation
Good maintenance, high reliability
Factory clean:
Traditionally uses Shanghai 3135 movement (less accurate)
Some models now have DD3285 movement (for Daytona)
The movement decoration of the new watch is closer to the original
Some old watches have slightly louder rotor noise
VS factory movement is accurate and reliable, wins
2. Case and strap quality
VS Factory
904L stainless steel construction (same as original)
Excellent weight distribution
End links are strong and well connected
Some models have slightly sharp case edges
Factory clean
Also uses 904L steel
Precise case shape, especially for Submariner
Better quality case engraving
Stronger feel of the strap, smoother buckle
Winner: Clean Factory, excellent case details, excellent strap quality
3. Dial and hands
VS Factory
Good color matching on most models
Luminous coating sometimes uneven
Date wheel position can be inconsistent
Excellent crystal clarity
Clean Factory
Excellent dial printing quality
Luminous coating consistency and color is better
“Clean” (pun intended) date wheel position
Cyclops magnifier is slightly better
Winner: Clean Factory, excellent dial details, better consistency
4. Bezel assembly
VS Factory
Clasp is smooth, but sometimes too stiff
Ceramic inserts are platinum-plated and accurate
Old bezels have a slight wobble when rotating
Clean Factory
Industry-leading bezel operation (smooth, perfect clasp)
Excellent depth and quality of inlay engraving
Minimal kickback when rotating
Clean Factory wins by a significant margin
5. Price and value: Not much difference between the two, Clean Factory slightly higher
6. Popular model comparison
Submariner 116610LN
Clean Factory Wins in case shape and bezel
VS Factory wins in movement and mirror
Datejust 41
Clean Factory has more dial options
VS Factory movement runs smoother
Daytona 116500
Clean Factory's DD3285 movement is more competitive
Clean Factory's subdials are smaller
Conclusion
For most buyers:
If you care about movement authenticity and long-term reliability, choose VS Factory.
If you care more about case details and visual perfection of dials, choose Clean Factory.
Both factories represent the pinnacle of Rolex replicas, and each excels in different areas. The "best" choice ultimately depends on which aspects of the watch are most important to the individual collector.
Note: This review is not absolute, but the final conclusion is consistent, that is, the quality of both factories is very good, each has its advantages, and is comparable.
1. Movement comparison
VS Factory
Uses self-developed VS3135 movement (for Submariner/Datejust) and VS3235 movement (for new watches)
VS3235 movement has 72 hours power reserve
Functions close to original, including smooth crown operation
Good maintenance, high reliability
Factory clean:
Traditionally uses Shanghai 3135 movement (less accurate)
Some models now have DD3285 movement (for Daytona)
The movement decoration of the new watch is closer to the original
Some old watches have slightly louder rotor noise
VS factory movement is accurate and reliable, wins
2. Case and strap quality
VS Factory
904L stainless steel construction (same as original)
Excellent weight distribution
End links are strong and well connected
Some models have slightly sharp case edges
Factory clean
Also uses 904L steel
Precise case shape, especially for Submariner
Better quality case engraving
Stronger feel of the strap, smoother buckle
Winner: Clean Factory, excellent case details, excellent strap quality
3. Dial and hands
VS Factory
Good color matching on most models
Luminous coating sometimes uneven
Date wheel position can be inconsistent
Excellent crystal clarity
Clean Factory
Excellent dial printing quality
Luminous coating consistency and color is better
“Clean” (pun intended) date wheel position
Cyclops magnifier is slightly better
Winner: Clean Factory, excellent dial details, better consistency
4. Bezel assembly
VS Factory
Clasp is smooth, but sometimes too stiff
Ceramic inserts are platinum-plated and accurate
Old bezels have a slight wobble when rotating
Clean Factory
Industry-leading bezel operation (smooth, perfect clasp)
Excellent depth and quality of inlay engraving
Minimal kickback when rotating
Clean Factory wins by a significant margin
5. Price and value: Not much difference between the two, Clean Factory slightly higher
6. Popular model comparison
Submariner 116610LN
Clean Factory Wins in case shape and bezel
VS Factory wins in movement and mirror
Datejust 41
Clean Factory has more dial options
VS Factory movement runs smoother
Daytona 116500
Clean Factory's DD3285 movement is more competitive
Clean Factory's subdials are smaller
Conclusion
For most buyers:
If you care about movement authenticity and long-term reliability, choose VS Factory.
If you care more about case details and visual perfection of dials, choose Clean Factory.
Both factories represent the pinnacle of Rolex replicas, and each excels in different areas. The "best" choice ultimately depends on which aspects of the watch are most important to the individual collector.
Note: This review is not absolute, but the final conclusion is consistent, that is, the quality of both factories is very good, each has its advantages, and is comparable.
Last edited: